
Listen to the Audio Shiur by Rabbi Yishai Natan:
1. The Origin of Ma’aser Kesafim
A. Where Do We Find Ma’aser in the Torah?
1. Avraham Avinu — Bereshit 14:20: After defeating the kings, Avraham gives Malki-Tzedek “ma’aser mikol” — one tenth of everything.
2. Yaakov Avinu — Bereshit 28:22: Yaakov promises Hashem: “Vechol asher titen li, aser a’asrenu lach.” Whatever Hashem gives him, he will separate one tenth. This is especially relevant because Yaakov is not talking specifically about agricultural produce. He makes a commitment involving everything Hashem gives him.
3. Aser Te’aser — Devarim 14:22: עשר תעשר את כל תבואת זרעך — The Torah commands separating ma’aser from agricultural produce. The question is whether there is also a Torah obligation to separate 10% of financial earnings.
4. What Is the Difference Between Ma’aser and Regular Tzedakah? The Ahavat Hesed explains that when a person gives ma’aser, Hashem becomes his partner in his business. Who better to have as your partner than Hashem?
B. The Famous Tosafot — Ta’anit 9a, s.v. Aser Te’aser
Tosafot quotes the Sifrei, which derives from the word “kol” that ma’aser includes: Ribit — interest earned on permitted loans. Perakmatia — profits from business. Kol she’ar revahim — all other earnings. This appears to be an explicit source for giving ma’aser from business profits. However, this passage does not appear in the standard editions of our Sifrei.
Hida, Birkei Yosef, Y.D. 249:3: Discusses the missing passage and its significance. This raises a major question: If the Torah itself includes financial earnings, why do so many poskim disagree about the obligation?
C. The Great Disagreement: Is It De’oraita, De’rabbanan, or Minhag?
1. A Torah Obligation: Based on the above, some poskim understand the early sources as giving ma’aser kesafim a Torah foundation. The question is whether the derashah quoted by Tosafot is a true Torah derivation or only an asmachta.
2. A Rabbinic Obligation: The Taz (Y.D. 331:32) and others hold that the derashah quoted by Tosafot is not a true Torah derivation, but rather an asmachta.
3. A Minhag: The Bach (Y.D. 331) maintains that ma’aser kesafim is not an independent Torah or Rabbinic obligation. Maharam of Rothenburg (Responsa, Prague edition, 74), quoted by Pithei Teshuvah (Y.D. 331:12), treats the practice as a minhag. The main reason for this position is that we do not derive halachot from midrashim or the Sifrei alone, but from the Gemara (Havot Ya’ir).
4. Rav Ovadia Yosef — Yehaveh Da’at III:76: Rav Ovadia rules like the Bach, that ma’aser kesafim is not a strict Torah or Rabbinic obligation, but rather a valuable and established minhag that brings blessing. However, once someone consistently adopts the practice, it can acquire the force of a neder unless he properly stipulated otherwise.
2. Does Giving Ma’aser Make You Wealthy?
A. The Promise of Wealth — Ta’anit 9a
The Gemara teaches: “Aser bishvil shetit’asher” — Give ma’aser so that you become wealthy.
The Gemara relates that Rabbi Yohanan asked the young son of Resh Lakish about this teaching. The boy told him that it could be tested. Rabbi Yohanan questioned how testing Hashem could be permitted, since the Torah says “Lo tenassu et Hashem.”
The answer was that ma’aser is an exception, based on Malachi 3:10:
וּבְחָנוּנִי נָא בָּזֹאת אָמַר ה׳ צְבָאוֹת אִם־לֹא אֶפְתַּח לָכֶם אֵת אֲרֻבּוֹת הַשָּׁמַיִם וַהֲרִיקֹתִי לָכֶם בְּרָכָה עַד־בְּלִי־דָי.
Hashem Himself invites us to test this promise. The Gemara describes the blessing as “ad beli dai” — until there is more blessing than a person can adequately express.
B. Does This Apply to Ma’aser Kesafim? — Rema, Y.D. 247:4
The Rema rules that charity brings wealth and discusses the permission to test Hashem. He also cites an opinion that specifically limits the permission to ma’aser, rather than all tzedakah. However, the pasuk in Malachi originally discusses agricultural tithes.
1. Testing Is Permitted With Ma’aser Kesafim: The language of the Rema is commonly understood to include financial ma’aser. The Hafetz Haim, in Ahavat Hesed, also supports applying the promise to financial giving.
2. The Permission Applies Only to Agricultural Ma’aser: She’elat Ya’avetz (I:3) challenges extending this exception to ma’aser kesafim. The Shalah similarly distinguishes financial ma’aser from agricultural ma’aser regarding testing Hashem. See Pithei Teshuvah (Y.D. 247:2), who brings this disagreement.
C. What About Someone Who Gives Ma’aser but Remains Poor?
Hashem has His reasons. This is similar to asking why bad things happen to good people and good things happen to bad people. It is a philosophical discussion that we will not address now.
3. How Much Must a Person Give?
A. The Three Levels of Tzedakah — Rambam, Matenot Aniyim 7:5; Shulhan Aruch, Y.D. 249:1
The main obligation is really to give 20%, as indicated by the double expressions “aser a’asrenu lach” and “aser te’aser.” Maran establishes three levels:
- 20%: Mitzvah min hamuvhar — the preferred level.
- 10%: Middah benonit — the ordinary level.
- Less than 10%: Ayin ra’ah — a poor measure of generosity.
However, Maran begins by saying that if a person can afford to provide for the needs of the poor, he should give according to their needs. This raises an interesting question: Is 10% the required amount, or merely a minimum standard of generosity?
For example, someone earning $5 million annually may give $500,000 to tzedakah. He has given his full ma’aser. However, if there are poor people who desperately need help, is he obligated to give more?
B. Does a Poor Person Have to Give Ma’aser?
1. Gemara, Gittin 7b: The Gemara teaches that even a poor person who survives on tzedakah must give tzedakah to others.
2. Rambam, Matenot Aniyim 7:5; Shulhan Aruch, Y.D. 248:1: Maran rules: אפילו עני המתפרנס מן הצדקה חייב ליתן ממה שיתנו לו — Even a poor person supported by charity must give some of what he receives to others. However, this does not necessarily mean he must give a full 10%.
3. How Much Money Must Someone Have to No Longer Be Considered Poor? Aruch HaShulhan (Y.D. 253:2) explains that Masechet Pe’ah establishes certain amounts that determine whether someone is considered poor and may receive leket and pe’ah. However, he explains that this depends on many factors and can change with the times. Therefore, each person should ask his Rav.
C. What if Someone Earns a Good Salary but Has Enormous Household Expenses?
Aruch HaShulhan, Y.D. 249:7: Ordinarily, household expenses are not deducted from profits when calculating ma’aser.
Rav Ovadia Yosef, Yehaveh Da’at III:76: Brings Avkat Rochel (Siman 3), who allows financially struggling people to calculate ma’aser after deducting necessary household expenses, but not in every case.
4. How Do We Calculate Ma’aser Kesafim?
A. Gifts and Inheritance
Generally, a person must give ma’aser from money he receives as a gift. However, he does not need to give ma’aser from objects he receives as gifts. The details are complicated, so a Rav should be consulted.
B. Salary: Gross or Net?
Aruch HaShulhan, Y.D. 249:7: Explains that a businessperson calculates ma’aser from actual net profits after deducting business expenses.
C. How Often Must Ma’aser Be Calculated?
1. Havot Ya’ir (224): The Havot Ya’ir discusses someone who profits from one business but loses money in another. Can he deduct his losses from his profits before calculating ma’aser? And what if he already separated ma’aser before the loss occurred?
He recommends keeping separate records of all profits, losses, and ma’aser contributions, and establishing a fixed accounting date every three or six months. At the end of each period, he calculates his total profits and losses and separates ma’aser from the remaining profit. Once that period ends, a new accounting period begins, and later losses cannot be deducted retroactively.
He adds that it is preferable to begin the accounting year on Rosh Hashanah, since the Gemara teaches that a person’s livelihood for the coming year is determined on Rosh Hashanah.
2. Sha’ar Ephraim (84): The Sha’ar Ephraim distinguishes between profits and losses from different business transactions, particularly when their individual results are already known. His approach is more restrictive about combining separate transactions than the Havot Ya’ir’s method of establishing a fixed accounting period.
3. Noda BiYehudah (Tinyana, Y.D. 198): The Noda BiYehudah disagrees with the Sha’ar Ephraim and supports making one general calculation of all business profits and losses over the year. He derives the significance of an annual calculation from the Yerushalmi (Pe’ah 1:1), which discusses separating homesh from earnings each year.
4. Aruch HaShulhan (Y.D. 249:7): The Aruch HaShulhan explicitly rules: וכן הוא דבר פשוט שהריוח מחשבין בכל שנה ושנה מראש השנה עד ראש השנה — “It is obvious that profits are calculated each year, from Rosh Hashanah to Rosh Hashanah.” He explains that all business profits and losses during that year are combined. A person then separates ma’aser from his net profits after deducting business expenses, but not ordinary household expenses.
5. Hafetz Haim (Ahavat Hesed, Part II, Chapter 18:2): The Hafetz Haim recommends calculating ma’aser every six months, or at least once a year, while keeping accurate records of income, expenses, and donations.
5. Where May Ma’aser Money Be Given?
A. Can Ma’aser Kesafim Be Used for Other Mitzvot?
There is a major disagreement between the Maharil, Maharam, Rema, Shach, Taz, and later poskim. The central question is whether ma’aser kesafim must be given specifically to poor people, or whether it may also be used for other mitzvot, such as supporting yeshivot, building batei kenesset, purchasing a Sefer Torah, supporting outreach organizations, or other communal projects.
There are two major approaches among the poskim, along with an important explanation from the Hatam Sofer that may reconcile them.
1. Maharil — Ma’aser Belongs to the Poor
Sources: Maharil, Hilchot Rosh Hashanah; Teshuvot Maharil 56; Rema, Y.D. 249:1.
The Rema rules: ואין לעשות ממעשר שלו דבר מצוה כגון נרות לבית הכנסת או שאר דבר מצוה רק יתננו לעניים — A person may not use his ma’aser money for other mitzvot, such as purchasing candles for a bet kenesset. Instead, he must give the money to the poor. The source is the Maharil, who explains that ma’aser money belongs to the poor.
The Maharil also discusses matanot la’evyonim on Purim. Even though the money is given directly to the poor, a person cannot simply fulfill an independent obligation using funds already designated for ma’aser.
2. Maharam of Rothenburg — Ma’aser May Be Used for Other Mitzvot
Sources: Maharam of Rothenburg, quoted by Maharshal and Derishah; Shach, Y.D. 249:3.
The Shach brings a different position in the name of Maharam: דכל מצוה שתבא לידו … אם לא היה יכולת בידו ולא היה עושה אותה מצוה יכול לקנות מן המעשר — If an opportunity to perform a mitzvah arises, and the person would not have had the financial ability to perform that mitzvah without using ma’aser money, he may use his ma’aser for it.
3. Be’er HaGolah — Perhaps There Is No Disagreement
Be’er HaGolah, Y.D. 249:1.
The Be’er HaGolah offers a way to understand the Rema and Shach together. He explains that the prohibition applies specifically to using ma’aser to fulfill a mitzvah that a person is already obligated to perform. However, when a person is not obligated to perform that particular mitzvah, he may use ma’aser money.
For example:
- Buying his own necessary tefillin would not qualify, since he is independently obligated to have them.
- Donating toward a communal mitzvah that he was not previously obligated to finance could qualify.
However, the Hatam Sofer strongly challenges this explanation.
4. Hatam Sofer — It Depends on What the Person Originally Accepted
Hatam Sofer, Y.D. 231.
The Hatam Sofer was asked about a father who promised financial support so his married son could study Torah with his father-in-law. He later found the payments difficult and wanted to use his ma’aser money.
The Hatam Sofer rejects the Be’er HaGolah’s explanation. He argues that the Maharil prohibits using ma’aser for another mitzvah even when the person is not independently obligated to pay for it.
Why? Because the Maharil maintains that ma’aser funds are designated for the poor. A person cannot take money belonging to the poor and spend it on candles for a synagogue simply because buying candles is also a mitzvah.
The Hatam Sofer compares this to a neder. If someone voluntarily accepts an obligation and designates money for it, he cannot later redirect those funds simply because the original obligation was voluntary.
However, the Hatam Sofer makes an important distinction: If, when beginning his practice of giving ma’aser, the person expressly stipulated that he could use the money for other mitzvot, even the Maharil could agree that those uses are permitted. Therefore, the issue is not merely whether the activity is a mitzvah, but also what the donor originally committed himself to give.
B. Practical Applications: Where Can Ma’aser Money Go?
1. Supporting Yeshivot and Kollelim
Supporting Poor Avrechim: A yeshivah or kollel collects money to provide stipends for avrechim who do not have enough to support their families. This qualifies as supporting needy people while also supporting Torah learning. It is therefore a particularly strong use of ma’aser.
Paying for a Yeshivah’s New Building: This raises the question of whether ma’aser may be used for other tzorchei mitzvah.
2. Purchasing a Sefer Torah
Meshiv Davar (II:75–76), Minhat Yitzhak (VIII:82), and other authorities discuss restrictions on purchasing a Sefer Torah with ma’aser funds, particularly because the purchaser may be attempting to fulfill his personal obligation. According to this approach, the purchase cannot necessarily be charged to ma’aser, even if the Sefer Torah will later be used by a synagogue.
However, Yalkut Yosef (Hilchot Sefer Torah, laws of writing a Sefer Torah, paragraph 7) explicitly rules: מותר לקנות ספר תורה מכספי מעשר כספים — He permits purchasing a Sefer Torah using ma’aser money. The ruling cites Me’il Tzedakah, Kenesset HaGedolah (Y.D. 249), and Derishah among its sources.
3. Purchasing Other Sefarim
Sources: Shach, Y.D. 249:3; Taz, Y.D. 249:1; Aruch HaShulhan, Y.D. 249:10; Hatam Sofer, Y.D. 232.
The Shach cites permission to purchase sefarim from ma’aser when a person could not otherwise purchase them and makes them available for others to study.
The Taz adds that the books should be marked as having been purchased from ma’aser funds, so the owner’s children will not mistakenly treat them as ordinary inherited property. However, the Aruch HaShulhan strongly questions this leniency.
Therefore, we must distinguish between three cases:
- Donating a set of Shas to a public bet midrash.
- Purchasing sefarim that are kept at home but freely lent to others.
- Buying personal sefarim exclusively for one’s own learning.
The third case has the weakest justification according to the sources permitting ma’aser for public Torah benefit.
4. Building or Supporting a Bet Kenesset
This is almost the exact case discussed by the Rema. He prohibits using ma’aser to purchase candles for a synagogue, even though the purchase is for a religious purpose.
According to the Maharil, constructing a synagogue would generally face the same objection. However, according to the authorities permitting ma’aser for other mitzvot, supporting a synagogue may be permitted under the relevant conditions. The Hatam Sofer’s discussion of the donor’s original stipulation is particularly relevant.
5. Purchasing an Aliyah or Other Honors — Taz, Y.D. 249:1
The Taz permits paying for a synagogue mitzvah from ma’aser if the person intended to do so when making the purchase, and the money goes toward an appropriate charitable purpose.
However, if he purchased the aliyah without intending to use ma’aser, he cannot afterward pay from ma’aser, because he would be satisfying an existing debt with those funds.
C. Can Ma’aser Pay for Children’s Tuition? — Rav Ovadia Yosef, Yehaveh Da’at III:76
Rav Ovadia discusses counting expenses for supporting children, including children older than six, toward ma’aser. Yalkut Yosef, Hilchot Tzedakah, also permits certain Torah education expenses to be paid from ma’aser. However, the details matter, and a Rav should be consulted.
D. Supporting Adult and Married Children — Rav Ovadia Yosef, Yehaveh Da’at III:76
Rav Ovadia discusses using ma’aser to support older children and help them establish their households. This can include helping children who are learning Torah. Many other poskim permit using ma’aser for this purpose.
E. Can Ma’aser Money Be Used to Purchase Raffle Tickets?
Igrot Moshe (O.H. 4:76:2): Rav Moshe Feinstein distinguishes between two types of raffles. If the organization sells a limited number of tickets, each ticket has an actual monetary value because of the chance of winning. Therefore, that value should not be paid from ma’aser. However, if the organization sells an unlimited number of tickets, the ticket has no definite value, and the payment is primarily a donation. In that case, one may use ma’aser money. If he wins, he may keep the prize, but Rav Moshe recommends returning the ticket price to ma’aser and giving ma’aser from his winnings to that organization. Shevet HaLevi (9:200) and Teshuvot VeHanhagot (3:289) are more lenient and permit purchasing charity raffle tickets with ma’aser money, even when the number of tickets is limited, because the raffle helps the organization raise money for tzedakah. However, Rav Haim Kanievsky maintains that if a ticket is purchased with ma’aser money, any prize won belongs to tzedakah. Therefore, whether one may keep the prize is itself a disagreement among the poskim. All these permissions assume that the organization is an acceptable recipient of one’s ma’aser funds.